Catholic Medical Quarterly Vol 76 (4) November 2026
The Trans dilemma and Catholic Schools
Dr Pravin Thevasathan
The
journalist Catherine Pepinster has stated that "Catholic schools have to
walk a tightrope when it comes to issues around transgender, negotiating
what the Church teaches and what the law requires." It is of course an act
of charity to provide support to children who experience gender dysphoria:
I know of a Catholic school where a girl who felt uncomfortable wearing
skirts was allowed to wear trousers. This seems a reasonable adjustment.
In 2024, the bishops' conference published a pastoral reflection called "Intricately Woven by the Lord" which states: "Whilst recognising with great love and compassion the difficulties individuals may experience with regard to gender variance, it is clear that all and especially the young need to be helped to accept their own body, as it was created."
What does "gender variance" mean? It is clear from a reading of the document that it refers to the subjective perception of the person suffering from gender dysphoria. This is clear enough to Pepinster: "So there is the message, loud and clear, from the Church: masculinity and femininity are static, imprinted irrevocably on creation by God." The Congregation for Catholic Education has described terms like "gender neuter" and "third gender" as a "fictitious construct."
Pepinster then examines the transgender policy at St John Fisher School in Rochester. Those of us who are devoted to St John Fisher will be shocked to learn that it states: " Gender is a spectrum which is not limited to male or female-but can span anywhere between these two binary points." As Pepinster notes, this statement contrasts with the bishops' conference for which "being male or female is fundamental."
We need a new St John Fisher to proclaim in charity and compassion the truths of our faith.
Reference
- The trans dilemma, by Catherine Pepinster, 14 March, 2026, The Tablet