Catholic Medical Quarterly Vol 76 (4) November 2026

Book Review
Shall He Find Faith On The Earth? A Critical Account Of The Crisis In The Church

by Claude Barthe Angelico Press

Reviewed by Dr Pravin Thevasathan

Faith on earthThis wonderful book is a work of charity and clarity. The author does not judge our leaders. He is more interested in facts. The fact that there is a crisis in the Church can no longer be denied. One example may suffice: the Catholic Church in Germany is effectively in a state of schism currently. The author takes note of the poor formation of priests in so many seminaries since the sixties. This has led to great confusion among the clergy, the bishops, and even popes. One example: Pope Francis appeared not to understand the term Co-Redemptrix. 

In order to understand what has happened, the author examines the impact of the Second Vatican Council. He does not claim the Council is invalid. But he does argue that there were ambiguities to be found in the documents themselves. After all, the Council was never intended to be a dogmatic Council. Its intentions were pastoral.

The opening of the Church to the world unfortunately did not lead to the planned evangelisation. Instead, a great deal of pollution entered inside the Church. Because the Council was pastoral, there was much ambiguity of terms. For example, the decree on Ecumenism did not even define what was meant by ecumenism. The declaration on Non-Christian religions did differentiate between traditional religions and spurious ones. From these initial ambiguities, we have fully developed ones: for example, that God wills different religious beliefs. 

All this confusion is because we are dealing with a Council that requires interpreting. Cardinal Burke interprets the Council in one way and Cardinal Cupich in another. 

The author argues that an ambiguous Council led to an ambiguous liturgy. He does not claim they are invalid. But the liturgy in Germany is frequently different to the liturgy in Poland. 

It is true that Pope John Paul attempted to interpret the Council in the light of Tradition. He therefore brought out Familiaris Consortio. Pope Francis chose to see the Council as a point of departure. He thus brought out Amoris Laetitia. So what should be the remedy? The author suggests that good bishops should continue to teach what has always been taught. And a well formed laity should follow what has always been taught and resist those teachings that contradict the Tradition