Catholic Medical Quarterly Vol 76 (4) November 2026

Correspondence

Of Soldiers and Statesmen, Priests and Physicians: John Henry Newman on medical ethics.

James E. Hurford

James HurfordSt John Henry Newman wrote widely on theology, philosophy, history, poetry and Church controversies. A field in which he has had limited recognition is medical ethics.

In the 1850s, Newman participated in a project to establish a Catholic university in Ireland. Although unsuccessful, it led to Ireland’s first medical school and one of Newman’s seminal writings; The Idea of a University. It is in this context that Newman contributed to medical ethics.

“Christianity and Medical Science”

On 4 November 1858, Newman addressed students at Dublin’s Catholic Medical School; the address is reproduced in The Idea of a University as “Christianity and Medical Science”.

Newman’s address has a recurring theme; the distinction between professional and higher moral norms. He urges his audience not to lose sight of the profession’s proper role and think of it as “all in all” [1]. He draws an analogy with the relationship between civilian and military leadership in wartime. While military leadership may have clear views on conducting a campaign, this may conflict with the civilian leadership’s needs; in such cases, military needs must yield, since “military success is not the highest of objects, and the end of ends, … but must ever be subordinate to political considerations or maxims of government, which is a higher science with higher objects.[2]”

Newman thus presents situations where one profession’s “best” must yield to other needs representing higher goods, and outlines the risk that an insular discipline, may become blind to values beyond itself, in particular to duties towards higher moral norms.

The Higher Moral Duty

What is this higher duty for physicians? In short, a duty to follow Divine Law.

Newman describes God’s Divine Law implanted into humanity as, “… the rule of ethical truth, the standard of right and wrong, a sovereign, irreversible, absolute authority” [3]. This is perceived by the individual’s conscience, which speaks within him and commands obedience [4]. Through conscience, the individual discerns Divine Law and applies it to concrete situations.

Newman recognised this sense is fragile [5]. While the material world is perceived objectively by the senses, Divine Law cannot be so observed; although its source is external, the individual relies on subjective phenomena within his own mind to perceive it. It follows that conscience could be seen as subjective; Newman elsewhere argues that in popular understanding, conscience had become “the right of thinking, speaking, writing, and acting, according to their judgment or their humour, without any thought of God” [6]. For Newman, conscience was not a facility for an individual to grant himself permission to act as he wishes, but by which he brings to bear moral principles. It concerns duty, not autonomy.

Conscience can err but nevertheless requires obedience [7]. It therefore requires proper formation. Newman argued;

The world is a rough antagonist of spiritual truth: sometimes with mailed hand, sometimes with pertinacious logic, sometimes with a storm of irresistible facts, it presses on against you. What it says is true perhaps as far as it goes, but it is not the whole truth, or the most important truth. These more important truths, which the natural heart admits in their substance, though it cannot maintain, - the being of a God, the certainty of future retribution, the claims of the moral law, the reality of sin, the hope of supernatural help, - of these the Church is in matter of fact the undaunted and the only defender. [8]

Thus, Newman returns to a higher law – Divine Law mediated through a conscience properly formed by Church teachings – standing above professional norms.

The medical profession

Medicine is a material science, concerned with man’s physical nature. The physical world’s greater hold on the mind leads to an “especial temptation and danger … it is a certain sophism of the intellect, founded on this maxim, implied, but not spoken or even recognized - ‘What is true is lawful’”[9]. A physician may concern himself with duties as a physician and forget moral and religious obligations. He may assume that what his professional obligations permit is moral.

Newman’s position is clear; where professional values and the higher duty conflict, professional values have no claim on obedience. He doesn’t say professional values are wrong; merely that they relate to the specific medical context. The higher moral duty must be determinative in disputes.

Newman’s remedy

Newman diagnoses medicine’s malady: inadequate understanding of higher moral duties arises from inadequately understanding other fields. A physician lacking this understanding views mankind in a material sense, in accordance with professional norms; this presents difficulties where, inevitably, questions arise which cannot be resolved solely by reference to professional norms. Without wider knowledge, a physician cannot identify and address questions relevant to the higher moral implications of his actions so that he;

… will think himself free to give advice, and to insist upon rules, which are quite insufferable to any religious mind, and simply antagonistic to faith and morals. It is not, I repeat, that he says what is untrue, supposing that man were an animal and nothing else: but he thinks that whatever is true in his own science is at once lawful in practice - as if there were not a number of rival sciences in the great circle of philosophy, as if there were not a number of conflicting views and objects in human nature to be taken into account and reconciled, or as if it were his duty to forget all but his own. [10]

Newman's audience is encouraged to seek guidance from the Church. More widely, he argues for moral instruction as part of professional formation. A physician so trained experiences a spectrum of ideas upon which he can draw in making moral judgements; this benefits professionals and society by producing a morally aware profession that considers duties above its own discipline.

Ongoing significance

Medicine’s healing capacity has improved since Newman’s day; however, while physicians may be able to do more for patients, less thought is given to moral implications of actions. Consider the question of whether what is medically indicated may be “humanly contraindicated” [11] issues such as “dignified death” and continuing treatment likely to be futile require physicians to balance concepts such as sanctity of life, autonomy, and dignity. Medical science is not necessarily equipped to answer such questions; it is only by forming physicians who “know something more than medical science” [12] that fully realised answers can be found.

Consider, too, the role of higher moral duties in addressing the profession’s moral shortfalls. Morally questionable but accepted practices may go unscrutinised. In such cases, change may come from doctors looking to a higher moral standard and acting upon conscience [13]. Indeed, a physician’s ability to morally reason may be as important as his ability to provide medical services [14].

More significantly, awareness of higher moral duties provides a check on any temptation for physicians to see their profession as all-important. Physicians are highly trained, highly educated, and presented as figures of great authority [15]. In a society in which medical ethics is dominated by secular philosophies [16] medicine may assume a particular moral authority. Sulmasy claims;

“… in an increasingly secular society, medicine now directly competes with the church for the role of transnational moral authority, supervening beyond all governments. The increasing medicalization of personal and social life provides a kind of alternative to the church. … Medicine is thus becoming something of an all-encompassing secular religion, competing for adherents.”[17] This perception may lead some to believe they have special moral insight [18]. In his day, Newman noted

“the most detestable advice given to young persons by eminent physicians, in consequence of this contracted view of man and his destinies” [19]. How much more should we be concerned when medicine wields the power over human life it now possesses? An understanding of higher morality and its relation to medicine might remind the profession of its limits.

To conform to higher moral norms, Newman envisages formation of individual morality, creating a medical profession of “enlightened conscience, broad sympathies, and ordered values”[20]. Ultimately, “Christianity and Medical Science” argues for physicians’ engagement in moral learning and contemplation to understand fields of knowledge which shape humanity’s moral sense

James E Hurford, LLB (Hons), LLM, MA, PGDip, Solicitor, unregistered Barrister

References

  1. Newman, J. H. The Idea of a University. Third Edition. London: Aeterna. (Originally published 1873). 335.
  2. ibid. 335.
  3. Newman, J. H. “A Letter addressed to the Duke of Norfolk, on occasion of Mr Gladstone’s Expostulation of 1874”. In Certain Difficulties felt by Anglicans in Catholic Teaching Considered: Volume 2. (Reprint 2010. Miami, FL: HardPress) (Originally published 1976). pp 171 – 378. 246.
  4. ibid. 248.
  5. ibid. 253-254.
  6. ibid. 250.
  7. Newman, J. H. An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of Assent. Worcester, MA: Assumption Press; 2013. (Originally published 1870). 71.
  8. Newman, J. H. The Idea of a University. 341.
  9. ibid. 337.
  10. ibid. 339.
  11. Gaffney, J. “Newman on Medicine and Morals”. Linacre Q. 1988; 55(2). pp 51-59. 57.
  12. ibid
  13. Birchley, G. “A clear case for conscience in healthcare practice”. J Med Ethics. 2012; 38(1): 13 - 17. 14.
  14. Bacon, L. “Conscientious objection to abortion”. Eur. J. Contracept. Reprod. Health Care. 2016:21(5): 414 - 415. 414.
  15. Newman, J. “Newman on Christianity and Medical Science”. Paideiusis. 1990: 3(2): 28-34. 33.
  16. Pellegrino, E. D. “The Physician’s Conscience, Conscience Clauses, and Religious Belief: A Catholic Perspective”. Fordham Urban Law J. 2002: 30(1): 221-244. 231.
  17. Sulmasy, D. P. “Can Medical Schools be Catholic?” Health Prog. 2003 84(4): 10-13. 12.
  18. Newman, J. “Newman on Christianity and Medical Science”. 33.
  19. Newman, J. H. The Idea of a University. 339.
  20. Gaffney, J. “Newman on Medicine and Morals”. 58.