Catholic Medical Quarterly Vol 76 (4) November 2026
Good clinical care at end of life: a response to Fr Pullicino
Jon Rogers
In his paper ‘End of Life “Care”, euthanasia and assisted dying’[1], published in this quarterly, Fr Patrick Pullicino – presumably well intentioned and with the best interests of patients at heart - makes various claims relating to end of life care (EoLC) and those who provide it, that are erroneous, misleading and do a disservice to compassionate and ethical clinicians. In this response I aim to point where his paper is in error, is thus misleading and how it might inadvertently lead to harm.
I respond from the perspective of a Catholic and of a pre-hospital clinician. I am an advanced paramedic and trainee advanced clinical practitioner (ACP), working in an ambulance trust’s urgent care team. Ambulance clinicians often get drawn into end-of-life (EoL) scenarios, usually when attending a patient whose decline suggests they may be approaching EoL; or where a gap in care is identified e.g. a terminal patient discharged home to their preferred place of death, but without anticipatory medications in place (medicines prescribed to be readily available “just in case” they are needed to provide relieve from pain, anxiety, agitation, nausea, vomiting or respiratory secretions) who is now experiencing distressing symptoms and in crisis; or where family are distressed and confused and don’t know how best support their dying relative. My training and role allow me to provide a level of senior support to ambulance colleagues, and I carry emergency doses of EoL medication to provide symptom control pending the prescription of anticipatory medications.
The issues with Fr Pullicino’s article can be considered in four categories:
- The fundamentally flawed paper underpinning it.
- His own misunderstandings.
- His own misrepresentation.
- His conclusions.
The underpinning paper
- The paper[2] underpinning Fr Pullicino’s article, although claimed as research, is more an opinion piece or at best an observational study. It does not stand up to critical analysis with examples of its many flaws including:
- Publication in a journal that what appears to lack academic weight.
- Five days from submission to acceptance, suggestive of inadequate or no peer review.
- A sole non-specialist author (a financial analyst) who denies there was a Covid pandemic[2] and claims that vaccination against Covid was more harmful than beneficial[3].
- Bias is clear from the opening paragraphs, the most evident being confirmation bias, citing his own earlier papers[3,4] to support his starting position that the pandemic was iatrogenic consequent to “COVID injections”.
- Misleads in his claim of a “flawed PCR test, which does not detect presence of the SARSCoV virus” while referencing a paper that is strongly supportive of RT-PCR[5].
- Demonstrates extensive misunderstanding including:
- claiming, in context of his concerns about midazolam, that “medication generally does not have instantaneous impact” to justify adjusting for a one-month lag in his data sets, demonstrating a misunderstanding of the pharmacokinetics of benzodiazepines and particularly midazolam with its comparatively short time to peak plasma concentration and short half-life[6].
- the use of midazolam in EoLC referring to it being “given intravenously in large doses continuously” when it is actually given subcutaneously in initial low doses and titrated to effect[6].
- what does – and does not – constitute a high consequence infectious disease (HCID)[7], inferring that being a HCID is a prerequisite for defining a pandemic. It is not: the WHO definition of a pandemic makes no reference to severity of disease[8].
- not understanding why those recently vaccinated were statistically analysed differently to those who were fully vaccinated, demonstrating a lack of understanding that protection is not instantaneous.
- Willingness to accept anecdotal “evidence” from a conspiracy theorist funeral director to support his thesis.
- Forcing a correlation between midazolam and excess deaths and then assuming causation, with no apparent consideration of confounders. I claim no expertise in applying the Bradford-Hill criteria[9], which Sy misappropriates in support his thesis. My own analysis satisfies me that the criteria clearly do not support a conclusion of causation.
- His assumed causation then extended to claim, without offering evidence, the deliberate killing of patients through “euthanasia of the elderly on a widespread and apparently co-ordinated scale”.
The misunderstanding
Fr Pullicino then repeats the flawed claims that spikes in deaths were due to the use of midazolam.
He misrepresents the nuance of NICE Guideline NG159. Although no longer extant nor readily available, an initial version still available online[10]. It evidences that the guideline did not rule out patients with a Clinical Frailty Score (CFS) of 5 or more being admitted to critical care but used it as an example of what should be considered in a holistic assessment while being “aware of the limitations of using the CFS as the sole assessment of frailty”.
Fr Pullicino frames midazolam and an opiate as “obligatory components of the EOLC pathway”. When a patient approaching end of life is prescribed anticipatory medications then this will most likely include midazolam (for agitation), an opiate (usually morphine, for pain and breathlessness) an anti-emetic and an anti-secretory.
These are also described a “just in case” (JIC) medications as they are prescribed to be available at short notice just in case they are needed. Having them prescribed clearly does not mean that they actually get used. Doses of midazolam are small, given subcutaneously (not IV as claimed by Sy[2]), not always via syringe-pump as Fr Pullicino implies[1}, and carefully titrated and thus not likely to cause “fatal respiratory depression”. The Palliative Care Formulary[6] states that “in the last days–weeks of life, the use of a benzodiazepine ± an opioid is not associated with shortened survival” citing a 2018 systematic review[11] and a retrospective study of hospice patients[12] in support. Additionally, a 2015 Cochrane review[13] suggested that even in the more extreme cases of benzodiazepines being used for pharmacological sedation, indicated for refractory symptoms, such “sedation did not hasten death”.
Fr Pullicino’s claim that dignity and comfort in EoL “pathways is in major part provided by tranquilisation with midazolam” represents a fundamental misunderstanding of the holistic nature of palliative and EoLC and is an injustice to those dedicated and caring clinicians that provide it. I have witnessed, in a hospice context, the cautious use and careful titration of midazolam to alleviate anxiety or agitation, but not to tranquilise. I have witnessed the compassionate conversation with a patient in intractable “total pain” where the option of using, and the potential sedating effect, of midazolam was discussed as part of shared decision making with the patient.
I agree with Fr Pullicino regarding not treating with a pre-set pathway. Thankfully the Gold Standards Framework (GSF)[14] and its advocacy and training for a ‘gold standard’ level of individualised proactive and personalised end of life-care is being increasingly adopted across the UK. This is what I see happening: personalised care, taking into account patient wishes and, where appropriate (i.e. recognising the primacy of patient's views/preferences when they have capacity), those of family. Fr Pullicino’s framing of current EoLC as a “pathway” is dated and misleading: the GSF is not a pathway, but a framework encouraging and enabling individualised care.
The misleading
Fr Pullicino’s outlining of “two remaining flaws from the LCP” is misleading.
While prognostication in terminal illness is challenging, I would argue that recognition of imminent dying is less so. Dr Kathryn Mannix in her beautiful book “With the End in Mind”[15] explains the signs eloquently and from extensive experience. I – and my nursing niece - recognised imminent dying in my own father after several weeks of decline, refusing food and fluids, then increasing sleep and reducing consciousness and later Cheyne-Stokes breathing. Occasional small doses of midazolam for agitation, and morphine in case pain was its cause, helped him to settle until he took, to paraphrase Dr Mannix, that out-breath which was not followed by an in-breath.
The research that Fr Pullicino references in relation to “self-fulfilling outcomes”[16], published 25 years ago, was a retrospective study of 87 patients relating to prognostication and support in a specific group of patients with catastrophic spontaneous intracerebral haemorrhage, treated in acute settings. I suggest that Fr Pullicino’s extrapolation and generalisation from this study is misleading and, at best, tenuous. It does not reflect the good EoLC given today across the UK, to people dying of terminal illness. My father was dying and the history and the signs were clear. The JIC medications did not kill him: he was on the cusp of death and they did what they were prescribed to do, alleviating distressing symptoms
The paper Fr Pullicino quotes as referring to “legal fiction” does so in the context of the challenge of making best interests decisions[17]. It makes no mention of the Mental Capacity Act (2005).
In Lady Hale’s Supreme Court judgement[18] family wishes do not get a mention, let alone as being “central”. Her judgement is about how an individual’s “past and present wishes and feelings” should be taken into account when making best interests decisions.
The conclusions
Fr Pullicino’s conclusions are misled, erroneous and misleading, and misrepresent those dedicated clinicians, whether of faith or not and including CMA members, who play a role in the compassionate care of patients suffering distressing symptoms in the days and hours as they approach death.
The paper by Sy [2] is disinformation and Fr Pullicino has been misled into using it as the basis of a thesis which is thereby inevitably flawed. It risks driving people away from good care and potentially pushes those persuaded to be fearful of end of life into the "compassionate" arms of Dignity in Dying, My Death My Decision and the rest of the assisted suicide lobby.
My appeal to CMA colleagues is several-fold:
- If something you read about – e.g. claims of a covert NHS agenda of involuntary euthanasia – sounds outlandish, then it probably is. Dig a bit deeper. But do keep an open mind – there are malign actors out there.
- If you have questions or concerns about end-of-life care, speak with an experienced colleague before coming to any conclusions.
- Read “With the End in Mind”.
- Get involved with Our Duty of Care (ourdutyofcare.org.uk).
Bibliography references.
- Pullicino P. End of Life ‘Care’, euthanasia and assisted dying. Catholic Medical Q. 2026 May; 76(2):13–14.
- Sy W. Excess Deaths in the United Kingdom: Midazolam and Euthanasia in the COVID-19 Pandemic. Med. & Clinical Research. 2024 Feb 15 [cited 2006 Jul 8]; 9(2):01–21. Available from: https://www.medclinrese.org/open-access/excess-deaths-in-the-united-kingdom-midazolam-and-euthanasia-in-the-covid19-pandemic.pdf
- Sy W. Early indication of long-term impact of COVID injections. Med. & Clinical Research [Internet]. 2023 Oct 20 [cited 2006 Aug 9]; 8(10). Available from: https://www.medclinrese.org/open-access/early-indication-of-longterm-impact-of-covid-injections.pdf
- Sy W. Australian COVID-19 pandemic: A Bradford Hill analysis of iatrogenic excess mortality. Journal of Clinical & Experimental Immunology [Internet]. 2023 Apr 1 [cited 2026 Aug 12]; 8(2). Available from: https://doi.org/10.33140/jcei.08.02.01
- Corman VM, Landt O, Kaiser M, Molenkamp R, Meijer A, Chu DK, et al. Detection of 2019 novel coronavirus (2019-nCoV) by real-time RT-PCR. Eurosurveillance [Internet]. 2020 Jan 23 [cited 2026 Aug 12]; 25(3). Available from: https://www.eurosurveillance.org/content/10.2807/1560-7917.ES.2020.25.3.2000045
- Wilcock A, Howard P, Stark Toller C, Droney J, Charlesworth S, editors. Palliative Care Formulary [Internet]. 2025 [cited 2026 Aug 11]. Available from: medicinescomplete.com
- UK Health Security Agency. High consequence infectious diseases (HCID) [Internet]. GOV.UK. 2018 [cited 2026 Aug 12]. Available from: https://www.gov.uk/guidance/high-consequence-infectious-diseases-hcid
- World Health Organisation. Pandemics [Internet]. 2026 [cited 2026 Aug 12]. Available from: https://www.who.int/health-topics/pandemics
- Bradford-Hill A. The Environment and Disease: Association or Causation? P. Roy. Soc. Med. [Internet]. 1965 May [cited 2026 Aug 12]; 58(5): 295–300. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1177/003591576505800503
- National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. COVID-19 rapid guideline: critical care in adults [Internet]. 2020 [cited 2026 Aug 1]. Available from: https://fssa.org.uk/_userfiles/pages/files/covid19rapidguideline.pdf
- O’Donnell SB, Nicholson MK, Boland JW. The association between benzodiazepines and survival in patients with cancer: A systematic review. J. Pain Symptom Manag. [Internet]. 2019 May [cited 2026 Aug 11]; 57(5):999–1008.e11. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpainsymman.2019.01.010
- Golčić M, Dobrila-Dintinjana R, Golčić G, Čubranić A. The impact of combined use of opioids, antipsychotics, and anxiolytics on survival in the hospice setting. J. Pain and Symptom Manage. [Internet]. 2018 Jan [cited 2026 Aug 11]; 55(1):22–30. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpainsymman.2017.08.004
- Beller EM, van Driel ML, McGregor L, Truong S, Mitchell G. Palliative pharmacological sedation for terminally ill adults. 2015 Jan 2. In: The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews [Internet}. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD010206.pub2. Record No.: CD010206
- The Gold Standards Framework. Welcome to Gold Standards Framework [Internet]. The gold standards framework. 2022 [cited 2026 Aug 1]. Available from: https://www.goldstandardsframework.org.uk/
- Mannix K. With the end in mind: dying, death and wisdom in an age of denial. London: William Collins; 2019.
- Becker KJ, Baxter AB, Cohen WA, Bybee HM, Tirschwell DL, Newell DW, et al. Withdrawal of support in intracerebral hemorrhage may lead to self-fulfilling prophecies. Neurology [Internet]. 2001 Mar [cited 2006 Aug 7]; 56(6):766–72. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1212/wnl.56.6.766
- Holm S, Edgar A. Best interest: A Philosophical Critique. Health Care Analysis [Internet]. 2008 July [cited 2026 Aug 7]; 19;16(3):197–207. Available from https://doi.org/10.1007/s10728-008-0092-x
- Aintree University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust v James [2013] UKSC 67. Available from: https://www.bailii.org/uk/cases/UKSC/2013/67.html