Catholic Medical Quarterly Vol 76 (4) November 2026
End of Life Care – a perspective from a Catholic intensivist and emergency physician
Dr Charlie O’Donnell FRCP FRCEM FFICM DA EDICM
Retired Consultant
in Emergency and Intensive Care Medicine
I read with great interest the article written by P. Pullicino, MD, PhD. Professor of Neurology and W.J. Burke, MD, PhD. Emeritus Professor of Neurology. Firstly, I must say the authors are clearly on the side of the angels as evidenced by their respect for the dignity of human life. I am a retired Consultant in Emergency and Intensive Care Medicine so end of life decision making was a constant theme in my day-to-day practice. Given the thoughtful reflection of these eminent Neurologists, I humbly submit my own thoughts to hopefully contribute to the discovery of moral truth.
1. I fully agree that a core human right is the right to life but this does not mean longevity at all costs irrespective of other goods. It means that the lives of innocent people e.g. patients must never be directly attacked. If the right is understood as longevity at all costs then Palliative Care pioneered by the Irish Sisters of Charity becomes a morally questionable speciality.
2. In my view the critique by the aforementioned authors of “A Catholic Guide to End-of-Life Decision-Making” released by the Catholic Bishops Conference of New York State on April 20th 2026 needs a slightly different analysis to reach the goal that we all share of doing the most amount of good that we can do in a fallen world and never doing evil so good may come of it.
3. The bishops have hit on some very important truths, but the language used has some potential ambiguities that can lead to misunderstandings. We must all remember Bishops do have the grace of state to teach so whilst they are not infallible their teaching deserves a very careful and charitable assessment before being rejected.
4. I think that the bishops should have clearly distinguished between the two types of ordinary care namely ordinary treatments and ordinary basic care. Providing or at least offering food and water by normal (biological) means is ordinary basic care in most situations. Providing food and water using a medical treatment, that is an intervention that assists the normal biological processes inherent in our biological nature must be assessed in terms of proportionality otherwise making treatments to provide food and water an immutable goal leads to absurdity. For example, if such a principle was adopted it would logically mean that the insertion of a cannula or nasogastric tube should occur in the treatment-resistant hypotensive, hypoxaemic patient who has a Cheyne Stokes respiratory pattern! This cannot be right.
5. It is vital to state that treatments are not de facto ordinary or extraordinary; they migrate depending on several counts the most obvious to doctors being physiological reserve or adverse events. Appendicectomy is an ordinary treatment in a physiologically robust 8 year old; it is an extraordinary treatment in a chemotherapy-resistant leukaemic 8 year old. It is the same with treatments like Nasogastric Tubes, Intravenous cannula and Subcutaneous portals: adverse events are common enough reasons to say enough is enough!
6. Pope John Paul correctly says the family are responsible for their loved ones and most especially there is strong scriptural support for vertical genealogical responsibility i.e. children honour your father and your mother, and parents love your children etc. How far the command goes with horizontal genealogical relationships is a bit more nebulous i.e. brothers, sisters, cousins etc as the person may have other more direct responsibilities as a primary responsibility. Does the priest as the only surviving relative of a cousin need to forgo his mission to provide support to his dying cousin? clearly this cannot be an absolute demand on the priest.
7. Also, the community responsibility must in the nature of things be one that enters the judgement about provision. This is because the provision of treatments be they ordinary or extraordinary is supplied by the community in one of four morally correct ways i.e. general taxation and healthcare free at the point of delivery, private insurance, direct payment or a mixture of the first two. All these systems have moral pros and cons but what is ordinary and should always be given is dependent on what is possible. The financial resource whatever system is adopted may not be available because of morally suspect or because of morally just reasons. The money may be needed for more vulnerable patients such as children instead of adults.
8. Thus, family and community costs are in the moral mix. Cost for the family is relevant when weighing benefits and burdens if the family will have to pay. Also cost for society can be relevant: a poor country may not have resources to do all that we in our privileged society would want for a dying person. Of course talking about costs here refers to the cost of the intervention itself and obviously not withholding with the aim of shortening a costly life. The latter action is euthanasia.
9. As regards the dying process: I agree this should be clarified but
reference to this process can be reconciled to sound moral practice. The
Liverpool Care Pathway
was fundamentally wrong because the criteria for
identifying the dying process were
wrong. It is very true that
predicting death without trials of therapy is fraught with problems. This
is why studies at the point of entry into medical care show very poor
predictive values regarding prognostication. Also, the studies include
multiple suspected pathologies all of which have vastly different natural
histories when they are given the benefit of time and good medical care.
However, it must be remembered as human beings we are not called to be
infallible in our decisions; we are called to use our wits to the best of
our abilities to do the most amount of good that we can and then we leave
the rest to God. If this is not the case no doctor could decide who waits
for an outpatient appointment and who is seen immediately. Healthcare
rationing (a form of distributive justice if done correctly) always runs
the risk that patients will die waiting to be seen. Thankfully we must
have sufficient human certainty not divine certainty.
10. The test of using our wits to the best of our ability regarding imminent death can be reasonably (not infallibly) met with strict physiological parameters such as 1. persisting intractable hypotension in the absence of dehydration or steroid deficiency, 2. Hypoxaemia despite supplemental oxygen, 3. established renal failure with urine output persistently below the volume obligataire, 4. loss of consciousness due to cerebral hypoperfusion and hypoxaemia.
11. In the dying patient, if possible, fluids should be given cautiously to assuage any thirst be it by NGT, SC or IV. As regards nutrition as with all people a judgement is made concerning calories, protein, vitamins and minerals: a three meals a day requirement, a once-a-day requirement or even feeding stopped for a few days. In the case of imminent death, the latter applies and thus nutrition is offered only prudently which in the case of death within say 24 hours means in effect it is not administered. Euthanasia is the intention to kill, not the intention to correctly judge the appropriate frequency of nutritional input. Clearly in a just and developed wealthy society it would seem very reasonable that ensuring the dying are comfortable and do not die from neglect should be high on the list in terms of tax money distribution.
12. It must be remembered that all treatments that aim to provide a
method to hydrate or provide nutrition can migrate from the realm of
ordinary to extraordinary. The table below gives some of the common
reasons for this change of goal posts.
| Type of treatment | Common reasons when this treatment migrates from ordinary and obligatory to
extraordinary and legitimately withheld in the dying patient |
|
Nasogastric tube to administer enteral nutrition and/or fluids |
1. Unable to pass the tube without intubation 2. Recurrent significant aspiration events 3. Unable to fix the ngt due to agitation or anatomical reasons 4. Extreme distress when the nasal mucosa is stimulated 5. Multiple episodes of tube migration leading to intra-oral coiling |
|
Peripheral intravenous line for the administration of fluids |
1. No veins despite adjuctive tricks such as highly experienced operator, failed multiple attempts, gtn spray dilatation, ultrasound identification and transdermal illumination 2. Recurrent rapid intravenous cannulae thromboses in the dying patient due to abnormal rheology resulting in sequential blocked cannulae 3. Paediatric cannulae in adult patients in small veins unable to provide adequate amounts of fluid without causing extravasation (“tissueing”) |
|
Subcutaneous line for the administration of fluids |
1. No significant soft tissue abdominal reserve due to loss of subcutaneous fat 2. Gross abdominal wall oedema so fluids just pool in the oedematous region with no significant contribution to general body hydration |
|
Syringed water or spooned water into the mouth in small aliquots little and often to hydrate |
1. Significant distressing aspiration events: coughing, retching, stridor, cyanotic episodes 2. Occasionally some patients seem to just drool possibly due to pharyngeal wall collapse so nothing goes in |
|
Intraoral soaked sponges to moisten lips and oral cavity |
No contra-indication |
In summary, thankfully usually it is easy and correct to provide some fluids by either an NGT or a cannula. But sometimes it is just not possible or indicated when death is imminent. No end-of-life decision is euthanasia unless the actual aim is to make someone die even if the decision is otherwise open to criticism such as claiming moral certainty on dubious grounds. Human life does come to an end and in my view the aim of the good clinician is to try to recognise when this is happening, ensure the comfort of the patient as much as is possible within the realms of justice and try to bring the spiritual reality of the imminent four last things into the care pathway. Therefore, if you are the clinician caring for me when my time comes please call the Priest as quickly as you call the Doctor!