Catholic Medical Quarterly Volume 73(2) May 2023
Response to Archbishop Paglia’s commentary on assisted suicide
AN
OPEN LETTER to His Excellency, The Most Reverend Archbishop Vincenzo
Paglia, President of the Pontifical Academy for Life and Members of the
Pontifical Academy for Life.
“Qui tacet consentire videtur.”
“He who
is silent is taken to agree.”
St Thomas More, former Lord Chancellor of
England, 1 July 1535.
Archbishop Paglia recently stated that “Personally I would not practice assisted suicide, but I understand that legal mediation can constitute the greatest common good concretely possible in the conditions in which we find ourselves.” (Emphasis added) Archbishop Paglia, President of the Pontifical Academy for Life, 19 April 2023 in a speech to the International Festival of Journalism in Perugia, Italy.
He also stated
- “I think that law 194 is now a pillar of our social life,” (Law 194/1978 legalised procured abortion in Italy)... in a subsequent question the interviewer asked Archbishop Paglia whether he intended to question this law, he replied: “No, absolutely, absolutely!” (Emphasis added) [1, 2]
As well as
- “It was an attempt, and certainly not a perfect one, to accept the invitation contained in Veritatis Gaudium (par. 3) for a radical paradigm shift in theological reflection, or rather – dare I say – at “a bold cultural revolution.” (Emphasis added) Archbishop Vincenzo Paglia in an interview on the book Theological Ethics of Life. Scripture, tradition, practical challenges. [3]
Regarding Assisted Suicide, Archbishop Paglia asserts that he understands “that legal mediation can constitute the greatest common good concretely possible in the conditions in which we find ourselves.” It can never be in the greatest common good to legalize a mechanism for a doctor to provide a patient with a poison with which to kill himself. There is no moral difference between this and the doctor or the nurse giving someone an overdose of morphine himself or herself. Your Excellency, Thou shalt not kill applies equally to both situations. Moreover so called “legal mediation” of assisted suicide is simply a tactical step in the process of facilitating the legalisation of euthanasia. In practice assisted suicide will be seen by doctors to be the moral hypocrisy that it is and open them to the practice of direct euthanasia.
The Statement published by the press office of the PAV [Pontifical Academy for Life] on 24 April 2023 following on the legitimate public outrage at his position is in itself misleading in proclaiming that “The President of the Pontifical Academy for Life, in full conformity with the Church’s Magisterium, reaffirms his “No” to euthanasia and assisted suicide” [4] whilst reiterating his support for a “legislative initiative” that would specify the conditions in which the crime is depenalised.
In order to avoid complicity and in the light of the above absence of an unequivocal correction and apology for this scandalous betrayal of vulnerable patients the remaining pro-life members of the PAV must ask Pope Francis to dismiss Archbishop Paglia, replacing him with a President who, with courage, unequivocally proclaims the perennial teachings of the Church and Saint John Paul both on life and on its legal protection.
Failing this these pro-life members should themselves resign from this discredited Vatican institution.
“Qui tacet consentire videtur.”
“He who is silent
is taken to agree.”
Resources and references
- (Video no longer available) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=psj8fnte-Dw (Alternative link to same reference from “Nuova Bussola Quotidiana” (NBQ) Youtube channel: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CC24DvVl8ds)
- https://www.catholicnewsagency.com/news/252147/taken-out-of-context-pontifical-academy-defends-archbishop-paglias-abortion-law-remarks
-
http://www.vaticannews.cn/en/vatican-city/news/2022-06/archbishop-vincenzo-paglia-pope-francis-interview-theological-et.html
Interview Question: Is the fact that there is free and open discussion in the book a sign of synodality?
Answer: “Of course. There is no other way, especially when it comes to such fundamental issues as those involving the multiple dimensions of human life. We followed a path of study and reflection that led us to see the issues of bioethics in a new light… It is certainly a process that reflects the synodal breath and climate in which Pope Francis wishes the Church to operate. This synodal process was authoritatively stressed during the workshop, by Cardinals Grech and Semeraro.” -
https://www.vatican.va/content/francesco/en/apost_constitutions/documents/papa-francesco_costituzione-ap_20171208_veritatis-gaudium.html#_ftn27
This vast and pressing task requires, on the cultural level of academic training and scientific study, a broad and generous effort at a radical paradigm shift, or rather – dare I say – at “a bold cultural revolution.” Veritatis Gaudium (par. 3) - https://www.academyforlife.va/content/pav/en/news/2023/paglia-end-of-life-statement.html
Yours Sincerely in Christ,
Dr. Thomas Ward
President
Mrs.
Christine de Marcellus Vollmer
Vice- President
Mr. Steven M. Mosher
Treasurer
Member’s Signature: and 28 others